Skip to main content
Parent 1
Parent 2
Parent 3
Parent 4

Trusted by 100K+ Parents

Which Math Curriculum Fits Your Child Best?

See each curriculum's strengths, then take Nicole's quiz — it starts with what's available at your student's level and ranks your options by fit.

Strengths at a Glance

What each curriculum does best

All four homeschool math curriculums Nicole teaches, side by side — every one covered by the same membership. Start with the option that sounds most like your child.

Math-U-See

Available now*

See the math with manipulatives

Good foundation for understanding how numbers are structured through the use of the manipulative kit.

May fit best if…

  • You want strong concept mastery before moving on
  • Your child learns best by building understanding with hands-on manipulatives
Levels

Alpha–Zeta

Pre-Alg. & Alg. 1 – Fall 2026*

Explore Math-U-See

RightStart Math

Aug 2026

Learning through discovery and play

Real application of math skills through hands-on manipulatives and games.

May fit best if…

  • Your child learns best through activities and discussion.
  • Mental math and strategy work matter to you
Levels

Levels C–F

Explore RightStart

Saxon

Repetition that makes it stick

Plenty of examples in the teaching and enough repetition for memory recall.

May fit best if…

  • Your child does well with repetition and routine
  • You want strong cumulative review
Levels

Math 3–Advanced Math

Explore Saxon

Singapore Math-Dimensions

Mental math & word-problem strategies

Good teaching of mental math strategies and a good framework for how to attack word problems.

May fit best if…

  • Your child enjoys understanding why math works
  • You want strong conceptual teaching
Levels

Grades 1–5

Explore Singapore
FIND YOUR STUDENT'S MATCH

Nicole's Math Match Quiz

Nicole will walk through the process she uses to evaluate a curriculum. Then you’ll go through the steps so you can find the best match for your student too!

The quiz will unlock at the end of Nicole's video.

Head-to-Head

Already down to two?

Pick your two finalists for a focused, feature-by-feature comparison of just those curriculums.

?

Contender 1

?

Contender 2

Compare

Pick a curriculum on each side

All Four Curriculums at a Glance

The same high-level ratings Nicole's matchmaker uses — side by side.

FeatureSaxon MathSingapore MathMath-U-SeeRightStart
Teaching PhilosophyTraditionalConceptualLeans TraditionalLeans Conceptual
Mastery vs. Spiral in TeachingStrong SpiralMostly MasteryStrong MasteryLeans Mastery
Mastery vs. Spiral in AssignmentsStrong SpiralStrong MasteryLeans SpiralMostly Mastery
Instructional StyleTeacher-LedMostly Student-DrivenBalancedStudent-Driven
Built-In PracticeMostLessMoreModerate
Mental Math InstructionMinimalExtensiveSomeModerate
Mental Math PracticeModerateLessMoreMost

Choosing Your Math Curriculum — Common Questions

Nicole the Math Lady offers Saxon Math video lessons from Math 3 through Advanced Math, Singapore Math-Dimensions video lessons for grades 1 through 5, and Math-U-See video lessons for Alpha through Zeta (Pre-Algebra and Algebra 1 arrive Fall 2026) — all with step-by-step teaching, practice support, and online grading. RightStart™ Math video lessons (Levels C through F) start releasing August 2026 — join the waitlist to be notified at launch.
Any of the four can serve a struggling student — the real question is why math is hard for them right now. If skills fade without regular review, look closely at how much built-in review a program has. If they can follow procedures but don't understand the concepts, look at how concretely a program teaches — visual models, manipulatives, and how quickly new ideas arrive. If worksheets themselves are the battle, consider how much of the practice is hands-on. And often the biggest difference isn't the book at all — it's the teaching: Nicole's video lessons break every step down in all four programs, so your student is never learning alone. Watch a sample lesson from each and notice which one your child responds to.
Yes. Many families switch curricula, especially if their current program isn't clicking. Two things to think through. First, every program sequences topics differently, so always start with the placement test for the new curriculum rather than assuming the same grade number carries over — and it's more than okay if it points a level back. Second, think about where your child is headed, not just where they are today: our video lessons cover Saxon from Math 3 through Advanced Math, Singapore Math-Dimensions grades 1–5, Math-U-See Alpha through Zeta (Pre-Algebra and Algebra 1 arrive Fall 2026), and RightStart Levels C–F starting August 2026. Watch a sample lesson from the new program before you commit, and let the placement test confirm the starting point.
For Saxon Math and Singapore Math-Dimensions you'll use your own textbooks alongside Nicole's video lessons. For Math-U-See you'll need the student workbook, instruction manual, test booklet, and the manipulatives for your child's level — the Integer Block Kit for Alpha through Delta, the Fraction Overlay Kit for Epsilon, and the Integer Block Kit plus the Algebra/Decimal Insert Kit for Zeta and Pre-Algebra. For RightStart™ Math you'll need the lesson/worktext materials and the Cotter Abacus and manipulatives for the level. Our video lessons are matched to specific editions — you can confirm exactly which editions we support, and where to buy them, on our textbooks page. If you already own materials, check that page to see whether your edition lines up; if you're not sure, reach out and we'll help you confirm before you start.
A typical Saxon or Singapore Math-Dimensions lesson takes about 45–60 minutes a day, including the video lesson, practice, and review — younger levels often run shorter, upper Saxon courses longer. Math-U-See paces differently: roughly one lesson per week, with your child watching the lesson and then working through that lesson's worksheets over several days until the concept is mastered. RightStart moves at about one activity-based lesson per school day — a lesson plus its games fills a daily math block. In every program, consistency matters more than volume — a steady daily rhythm beats long, occasional sessions.
Math-U-See video lessons are available now for Alpha through Zeta — Pre-Algebra and Algebra 1 arrive Fall 2026 — and every Math Pass starts with a free trial that includes them. RightStart™ Math is next, with release starting August 2026; we offer a free trial for every course we publish, so one will be available when it launches. Join the RightStart waitlist to be the first to know when it goes live.
Less than you might expect — with Nicole's video lessons doing the teaching and online grading doing the checking, all four programs can run largely hands-off for you day to day. The honest difference is in how each program practices: worksheet-based programs let a student work independently after the video lesson, while RightStart is intentionally built around parent-led games and hands-on activities — wonderful if you want that shared time, worth knowing if you don't have it. Ask yourself how many minutes a day you can genuinely sit alongside your child, and let that answer guide you.
First, you're not alone — many families arrive after several tries, and the right fit is usually about how a program presents ideas rather than its name. Questions worth asking: Does my child understand better when they can touch and move something — blocks, an abacus, drawings — rather than look at a page of numbers? Do they need to stay on one concept longer, without new topics crowding in? Is a full page of problems overwhelming, so fewer-but-deeper would work better? Does color and imagery help them focus, or distract them? Each of the four programs answers these differently, every one lets you slow the pace to your child's needs, and Nicole's videos re-teach each step as many times as your student wants to watch. Try the free sample lessons side by side and watch your child's reaction — that usually says more than any review. Then use the placement test to find the right starting point — and you're always welcome to reach out so we can help you think it through.