Trusted by 100K+ Parents
Which Math Curriculum Fits Your Child Best?
See each curriculum's strengths, then take Nicole's quiz — it starts with what's available at your student's level and ranks your options by fit.
What each curriculum does best
All four homeschool math curriculums Nicole teaches, side by side — every one covered by the same membership. Start with the option that sounds most like your child.
Math-U-See
Available now*See the math with manipulatives
Good foundation for understanding how numbers are structured through the use of the manipulative kit.
May fit best if…
- You want strong concept mastery before moving on
- Your child learns best by building understanding with hands-on manipulatives
Alpha–Zeta
Pre-Alg. & Alg. 1 – Fall 2026*
RightStart Math
Aug 2026Learning through discovery and play
Real application of math skills through hands-on manipulatives and games.
May fit best if…
- Your child learns best through activities and discussion.
- Mental math and strategy work matter to you
Levels C–F
Saxon
Repetition that makes it stick
Plenty of examples in the teaching and enough repetition for memory recall.
May fit best if…
- Your child does well with repetition and routine
- You want strong cumulative review
Math 3–Advanced Math
Singapore Math-Dimensions
Mental math & word-problem strategies
Good teaching of mental math strategies and a good framework for how to attack word problems.
May fit best if…
- Your child enjoys understanding why math works
- You want strong conceptual teaching
Grades 1–5
Nicole's Math Match Quiz
Nicole will walk through the process she uses to evaluate a curriculum. Then you’ll go through the steps so you can find the best match for your student too!
The quiz will unlock at the end of Nicole's video.
Already down to two?
Pick your two finalists for a focused, feature-by-feature comparison of just those curriculums.
Contender 1
Contender 2
Pick a curriculum on each side
All Four Curriculums at a Glance
The same high-level ratings Nicole's matchmaker uses — side by side.
| Feature | Saxon Math | Singapore Math | Math-U-See | RightStart |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Teaching Philosophy | Traditional | Conceptual | Leans Traditional | Leans Conceptual |
| Mastery vs. Spiral in Teaching | Strong Spiral | Mostly Mastery | Strong Mastery | Leans Mastery |
| Mastery vs. Spiral in Assignments | Strong Spiral | Strong Mastery | Leans Spiral | Mostly Mastery |
| Instructional Style | Teacher-Led | Mostly Student-Driven | Balanced | Student-Driven |
| Built-In Practice | Most | Less | More | Moderate |
| Mental Math Instruction | Minimal | Extensive | Some | Moderate |
| Mental Math Practice | Moderate | Less | More | Most |